Best material for flat bay window roof & quote advice?

We have had a roofer round to look at our bay window roof which has a fairly large crack in the leadwork. He has provided quotes for replacing the existing boards (which are apparently sodden after a rainy weekend) and the roof covering itself plus lead. What's the best material to go for here - both in terms of longevity and appearance? I am a bit concerned that rubber could look ugly and out of place in a Victorian terrace. 75% of the other houses have lead and the rest look to have felt - which looks pretty awful. Images here: https://imgur.com/a/0PjF0Wh

9 Answers

My opinion would be rubber it’s very long lasting and looks a lot better than felt.
14th May 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 151
Post your job & get responses from local roofers. Read reviews before you decide to hire.
I'm looking for ...
0 Reviews
Fibreglass is the best solution 100% in my eyes
26th May 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 149
BK Roofing
0 Reviews
I would roccomend Firestone rubber cover comes with a nice set of trims, but if you don't like the look of it can go back with lead
27th May 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 145
Hi there I would say a 3 layer felt system as it is durable in hot/cold weather and it’s life time is 25+ years
7th Jul 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 143
Have you considered putting a lightweight slated roof instead of lead or other materials. There is every chance your main roof is slated so the canopy should blend in nicely with a used slate. I am assuming it's only a smallish canopy so not many slates would be required but you would require some timber work to support the slate roofing etc. Hope that Helps.
8th Jun 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 141
Lead are the best to use also last longer and got more for the money worth
11th May 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 139
Hi there , grp ( grey fibreglass) is the best option
13th Jul 2020
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 127
Lead work would be the best to keep the in keeping of the style and age of the property of course this will be expensive rubber is a great product and with the trims it looks very neat and tidy on any property
12th Jan 2023
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 44
First class roofs
0 Reviews
Best thing is to relay boards and use breathable underfelt and top layer of bitumen felt
20th Feb 2024
Helpful Answer? Vote Up thumb up + 8
Post your job & get responses from local roofers. Read reviews before you decide to hire.

I'm looking for ...

How it Works

step1
Read reviews before you decide to hire.
See how it works